Face It: Social Security Is Welfare
According to the dictionary, “welfare” is a word that describes our health, happiness, and fortunes. But in the US, it usually refers to government support, which many consider shameful. No one wants to be “on” welfare.
But in fact, almost all of us are on welfare… or will be eventually. That’s because most Americans will someday reach retirement age and collect Social Security benefits… and Social Security is welfare.
About half of you reading this are flipping out right now. How dare he say that? That’s my money! I earned every penny of it!
Photo: Getty Images
I’m sorry, but no, you didn’t earn it—at least not all of it. Social Security benefits are a gift from other taxpayers. It’s not simply your own money coming back to you.
That may be hard to accept, but it’s important. Recognizing it should change your financial decisions. Yet almost no one ever thinks about it.
Simple Math
Last week, John Mauldin wrote about the US government’s massive “unfunded liabilities.” He used an interesting metaphor to explain why people often don’t recognize it as debt.
Debt can be less specific, too. Maybe, while taking your family on a beach vacation, you notice a wedding taking place. Your 12-year-old daughter goes crazy about how romantic it is. In a moment of whimsy, you tell her you will pay for her tropical island beach wedding when she finds the right guy. That “debt,” made as a loving father to delight your daughter, gets seared into her brain. A decade later, she does find Mr. Right, and reminds you of your offer. Is it a legally enforceable debt? Probably not, but it’s at least a (now) moral obligation. You’ll either pay up or face unpleasant consequences. What is that, if not a debt?
Later, John applied the comparison to Social Security.
Think back to my example of promising your daughter the beach wedding. That is sort of what is happening with Social Security, if you had accompanied the promise by asking your daughter to save a nickel a week toward paying for it. The resulting $28 after ten years would not begin to cover the cost, but your daughter will rightly argue she did her part. You will be on the hook for the rest, just as Congress will be on the hook with angry retirees who think they “paid” for their benefits.
John is exactly right, and we know this because Social Security is going broke, as I wrote last month. All would be well if the taxes people paid into Social Security were enough to cover the benefits they receive. That’s just math.
“Ah, but Congress spent the money on other things,” you might say. That doesn’t matter. Congress borrowed cash from the Social Security trust funds and replaced it with IOUs. Social Security still “owns” all that money… and it’s not enough.
Photo: Getty Images
Too Generous
The core problem is that Social Security benefits are more generous than the taxes collected can cover. That has always been the case. Ida May Fuller, the very first Social Security recipient in 1940, won the proverbial lottery.
Ida May Fuller worked for three years under the Social Security program. The accumulated taxes on her salary during those three years was a total of $24.75. Her initial monthly check was $22.54. During her lifetime she collected a total of $22,888.92 in Social Security benefits.
The original idea was that most people who paid into the system would die before collecting much (if anything), thereby covering the longer-lived minority. That didn’t happen, because life expectancy rose.
Instead of recognizing this fact and adjusting the formulas, we plunged merrily ahead, and here we are. The government can’t pay your Social Security benefits at the current level unless it taxes other people to get the cash.
As a practical matter, Social Security works much like subsidized housing for low-income people. You pay something for what you get, but not the full amount. That why I call it “welfare.” And unlike other welfare programs, it’s not means-tested.
Photo: Getty Images
Plan a New Career
Having said Social Security is welfare, let me be clear: I don’t think that is bad. The US is a wealthy country. We can afford to keep our oldest people comfortable in their final years. The question is how to do it. The present system is not sustainable.
We could make it sustainable, maybe. The last trustee report explained how.
[T]o remain fully solvent throughout the 75-year projection period: (1) revenues would have to increase by an amount equivalent to an immediate and permanent payroll tax rate increase of 2.78 percentage points to 15.18 percent, (2) scheduled benefits would have to be reduced by an amount equivalent to an immediate and permanent reduction of about 17 percent applied to all current and future beneficiaries.
The trustees say higher taxes, lower benefits, or some combination of the two would fill the gap. Their estimate depends on some assumptions that could be wrong, so it may still not be enough. It would be a start, though—and Social Security wouldn’t be welfare anymore.
I still think the best solution is to increase the retirement age. You can do that even if Congress doesn’t require it, and I think you should. Forget about retiring at 65 or even 70. Instead, plan a new career that you can “retire into” and generate your own income, for as long as you’re physically able.
That’s my plan. If I ever get anything from Social Security, I hope not to need it. I’ll regard it as a bonus… and I’ll thank the younger generation that gives it to me.
See you at the top,
Patrick Watson
@PatrickW
Scroll down for comments.